Skip to main content
Judiciary NI

Main menu

  • Home
  • You & the Judiciary
    • Court Guidance
    • List of Judiciary of Northern Ireland
    • Coroners
    • Lay Magistrates
    • Court Sittings and Court Structure
    • Attending Court
    • Lady Chief Justice's Sentencing Group
    • Judicial Conduct and Complaints
    • Judicial Attitude Survey
  • Judicial Training
    • Who are the Judicial Studies Board?
    • Judicial Studies Board Membership
    • Judicial Studies Board Publications
    • Lay Magistrates' Training Committee
    • Lay Magistrate Training Event Papers
    • Lay Magistrates Resources
    • Judicial Studies Board Contacts
    • Useful Links
  • Reviews & Modernisation
    • Civil and Family Justice Review
    • Shadow Civil Justice Council
    • Shadow Family Justice Board
    • Digital Modernisation
    • Cross Jurisdiction Conference
  • Legacy
    • Legacy Litigation
    • Legacy Inquests - General
    • Ballymurphy Inquest
    • Patrick McElhone Inquest
    • Neil John McConville Inquest
    • Thomas Friel Inquest
    • Thomas Mills Inquest
    • Springhill Inquest
    • Kathleen Thompson Inquest
    • Coagh Inquests
    • Stephen Geddis Inquest
    • McKearney & Fox Inquest
    • Leo Norney Inquest
    • Kingsmill Inquest
    • Clonoe Inquest
    • Francis Bradley Inquest
    • Patrick Crawford Inquest
  • Judicial Decisions & Directions
  • Publications
    • Sentencing Guidelines for Northern Ireland
    • Sentencing Guidelines - Magistrates' Court

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Sentencing guidelines - Totality / Consecutive
  3. Totality / Consecutive
  4. 2024

Sentencing guidelines - Totality / Consecutive

Skip to results

Search decision and choose filters to show only the results you want

Filter search results

Date

  • 2024 Selected filter: remove filter 2024
  • March 2024 (2results)

Type

  • Totality / Consecutive Selected filter: remove filter Totality / Consecutive
  • Blackmail (3results)
  • Deterrence (1results)
  • Drug Offences (1results)
  • Indecent Images (3results)
  • Life Sentences – Discretionary (2results)
  • Life Sentences – Mandatory (2results)
  • Manslaughter (2results)
  • Multiple Issue Sentencing Cases (1results)
  • Offences (1results)
  • Orders Ancillary to Sentence (1results)
  • Personal Mitigating Circumstances – Exceptional Circumstances (2results)
  • Road Traffic Offences (1results)
  • Sexual Offences (8results)
  • Terrorist Offences (2results)
  • Theft and other Dishonest Offences (2results)

2 results

22 March 2024

The King v Gavin Coyle

The Court of Appeal adopts, at paragraph [37] and [38], the principles set out in R v Green [2019] EWCA Crim 196 when deciding what, if any, impact a previous sentence for similar related offences should have when passing the new sentence.

DPP reference and application for leave to appeal the six year sentence by the defendant – terrorism offences - whether 12 year starting point correct – whether there was culpable delay for which a deduction from sentence should have been made – totality - appellant had, since the index offences took place, been sentenced to 10 years imprisonment in 2014 in respect of terrorism offences - whether max credit should have been given for the guilty plea – sentence unduly lenient – leave granted – substituted a sentence of 8 years imprisonment (2/3 in custody) – appeal dismissed

[2024] NICA 22 Keegan LCJ

08 March 2024

The King v Jonathan Hutton

At paragraph [58] of this judgment the Court of Appeal, while decrying an unduly mechanistic approach, provides guidance to assist sentencing judges when dealing with multiple offence, multiple victim cases.

Application to appeal a sentence of 12 years imprisonment – variety of sexual offences – two young female victims – totality – transparency - a sentence in the region of 11-12 years held to be appropriate - appeal dismissed

[2024] NICA 19 Keegan LCJ
Lady Chief Justice’s Office
Royal Courts of Justice
Chichester Street
Belfast
BT1 3JF
 
Email: LCJOffice@judiciaryni.uk
Telephone: 028 9072 4616 or 028 9072 4615
  • Follow us on Twitter

Footer links

  • © Crown Copyright
  • Cookies
  • Terms and conditions
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Data Privacy